Skip To Content

Events

Apr 19 2024

CABE Webinar: Evaluating Different Approaches to Measuring Owned Accommodation in the Consumer Price Index

The Canadian CPI measures the change in the cost of a fixed basket of goods and services typically purchased by Canadians. These include shelter (housing services), an important element of consumer spending. Owned accommodation (OA) accounts for more than half of these expenditures.

There are several approaches for the treatment of OA in the CPI. The rental equivalence approach gauges the cost of homeownership as if owners were renting their properties to themselves. The user cost approach considers the perceived costs of owning a home, while the payment approach assesses actual housing expenses.  The (net) acquisition approach treats an owner-occupied dwelling like any other CPI household durable good, measuring the cost paid by a household to acquire a house (including or excluding the land). Finally, one approach excludes OA in the CPI as it considers OA as a pure asset and therefore excludes from the CPI any effect of price change related to the purchase and use of an OA.

In addition, the treatment of OA is an integral part of the discussion on how to explain the gap between perceived inflation (measured by the Bank of Canada’s Canadian Survey of Consumer Expectations) and measured inflation. The difference between the price of a house (or how much it costs to buy a house) and the cost of owning a house can be a source of confusion that affects consumers’ perception of inflation, potentially widening the inflation perception–measurement gap.

The objective of this paper is to review the pros and cons of each available approach to measuring OA and determine how analytical CPI inflation would vary with each approach, especially in the context of high inflation. By applying each of these approaches to estimate OA, the paper presents several analytical index series for the CPI and evaluate each approach in the Canadian context using several criteria, including the purpose of each approach, practical considerations, volatility and data limitations. Finally, it also highlights the implications for monetary policy and the gap between inflation perception and measurement.

The analysis demonstrates that the official treatment of owned accommodation used in the Canadian CPI remains the best approach for Canada. This approach is aligned with the conceptual purpose of consumer price indexation, balances the various uses of the CPI by limiting volatility, and can be produced using available data sources.

Patrick Sabourin 2 Patrick Sabourin Senior Policy Advisor. Canadian Economic Analysis, Bank of Canada

Patrick Sabourin is Senior Policy Advisor at the Bank of Canada.  He previously worked at Finance Canada.  He is a member of the Price Measurement Advisory Committee (PMAC) for Statistic Canada.  He supervised work related to the Canadian Survey of Consumer expectations and advises senior management on key policy developments and price measurement issues. He has presented and authored/co-authored a number of reports on CPI inflation including: the size of the bias in the CPI, measuring durable goods and housing prices in the CPI and limitations of measures of owner-occupied housing in the CPI. Patrick has a Master’s degree in economics from the University of Quebec.

FaouziTarkhani_cropped Faouzi Tarkhani Senior Economist. Consumer Prices Division, Statistics Canada

Faouzi Tarkhani is a Senior Economist at the Consumer Prices Division of Statistics Canada. He has managed several statistical programs, including the 2011 Canadian CPI Basket Update, Canadian inter-city price indexes, and Canadian productivity statistics programs. Tarkhani has made significant contributions to the enhancement of CPI calculation and is the designer of the capital service measure used in the Canadian Multifactor Productivity Program.

Tarkhani is an IMF Price Statistics Advisor since 2013, and has authored numerous professional articles published in leading economic journals, such as OECD Economic Studies, Canadian Public Policy, Actualité économique, Monthly Labor Review, among others. He has been a Chartered Financial Analyst since 2002 and holds a Master’s degree in finance from the University of Montreal.

 

Event Details

Virtual
Apr 19, 2024 13:00 - 14:30 EST

Event Registration Closed.

Public Attendee List

  • CABE Manager
  • Diana Petramala
  • Erik Johnson
  • Justin Desrosier
  • Ryan Biln
  • Justin Desrosier
  • Sungmin Yoon
  • Justin Desrosier
  • Rebekah Young
  • Lan Do
  • Annie De Champlain
  • Laura Gu
  • Ted Tsiakopoulos
  • John Hoicka
  • W. Gray Giovannetti
  • Phil Stone
  • Kiefer Van Mulligen
  • Rowena Ahsan
  • Peter Tseng
  • Vikram Rai
  • Michael Abramson
  • Davis Dolan
  • Robin Banerjee
  • James Orlando
  • Melville McMillan
  • Ning Huang
  • Atousa Mirzaei-Rezaei
  • Mario Baker
  • Jeff Bennett
  • Brendon Ogmundson
  • Jing An
  • Antonia Prlic
  • Charles St-Arnaud
  • Lawrence Schembri
  • Tina Liu
  • JME Maxwell
  • Patrice Rivard
  • James Marple
  • Aaron Sydor
  • Katarina Michalyshyn
  • Marina Savchenko
  • Robin Banerjee
  • Tariq Shahriar
  • Randall Bartlett
  • Peter Harrison
  • Tiago Figueiredo
  • Ryhan Chand
  • Thomas Stow
  • Ryan Biln
  • Caroline Nicol
  • Vikram Rai
  • Holly Chisholm
  • Mary Kenny
  • Jonathan Erling
  • Shaun Cathcart
  • Crystal Arnburg
  • Clifford Halliwell
  • Farah Omran
  • James Orlando
  • Hasina Rasata
  • Steve Dorey
  • Narendra Budhia
  • Caroline Whitby
  • Steve Dorey
  • Zachary Vrhovsek
  • Clement Yelou
  • Peter Tseng